Young people have to think about their educational path earlier and earlier, from middle school and even more so in high school, and most of them go through this moment with anxiety. Career guidance was born at the beginning of the twentieth century to match a profile with an occupation, and when a young person asks us for advice about their studies, we often do the same thing with what our own path has taught us, assuming we know more than they do. Yet that path took place in a world that has changed a great deal since, and what we know of it is what the philosopher Donna Haraway calls situated knowledge. Drawing on the psychologist Jean Guichard, the anthropologist Margaret Mead, Donna Haraway and the philosopher Michel Serres, I suggest advising differently: first listen to what the person wants to do, take an interest in what they already do, including with their phone, and then say frankly where the advice you give them comes from.
Choosing at fifteen
According to the 2026 Parcoursup Barometer published by the French Ministry of Higher Education, 52% of high school students say they think about their educational path before even starting high school, 35% of them as early as middle school, and 82% find the procedure stressful (Parcoursup is the national platform through which students apply to higher education). Since the 2019 reform of the baccalauréat (which abolished the S, ES and L streams of the general track), students choose at the end of their first year of high school, around the age of fifteen, the specialised subjects they will take the following year, and almost two years later, the committees that examine their applications on Parcoursup look at which subjects they kept. Parents are worried too. In early 2026, the magazine l’Étudiant and the FCPE parents’ federation surveyed 1,103 parents: 77% say they feel anxious about guidance after the baccalauréat, and 45% a sense of powerlessness.
This anxiety is also about the future itself. In The beginning of a future for the Left, I recalled that a person born between 1950 and 1980 could hope, thanks to their studies and their work, to rise above their parents’ situation, buy a flat, look forward to a decent retirement. For a large share of today’s young people, housing and social position depend more and more on what they inherit. The adult a young person asks for advice has often grown up in the first world, and reassures them with what they know of it: study, and you will find a good job. Because we have studied, worked, hesitated ourselves between several paths, we think we know more, and we pass this knowledge on from the top down.
Does an adult really know more? I think rather that they know something else. In 1988, the philosopher of science Donna Haraway published an essay entitled “Situated Knowledges”, translated into French in Manifeste cyborg et autres essais (Exils, 2007). She explains that all knowledge is produced by a person who occupies a precise place, with their body and their history, and that scientists are more objective when they say where they speak from than when they claim to look at the world from nowhere. I took up this notion in Cultural democratization, cultural democracy : situated definitions, to understand why colleagues who, like me, are committed to cultural rights do not put the same thing behind the same words. The advice “study, and you will find a good job” is knowledge of this kind. It was true for many people born between 1950 and 1980, and it is much less true for someone who is seventeen in 2026. Young people, too, have situated knowledge, that of the world they already live in, of their tools and their friends, and on that ground they often know more than we do. Advising then means bringing two situated forms of knowledge together, and getting them to talk to each other.
An expert who convinces
When a young person asks you whether they should enrol at university or in a specialised school, what do you do? Most of the time, we answer from our own experience, or from what we have seen around us, in a nephew, a colleague, etc. An aunt will say: “if I were you, I would choose the school, because there are internships.” A family friend will say the opposite: “do a university degree first, it will keep your options open.” These pieces of advice are completely opposed, and in the end it is rather incoherent: how is the young person supposed to find their way? The adults tell them things that miss the point, since they contradict each other, whereas the young person needs to be accompanied on their own path. That they can be given opposite advice is proof enough that this advice is not advice for them. Afterwards, of course, they do what they want with it. Our reflex of answering is generous, and it has a history.
The psychologist Jean Guichard, who was a guidance counsellor before teaching at the Conservatoire national des arts et métiers, traced this history in “Problématiques et finalités du conseil en orientation”, an article published in 2002 by the European journal of Cedefop, Vocational Training (no. 26). Guidance professions were born at the beginning of the twentieth century in industrialised countries. The aim was then to match a person and an occupation, mainly according to young people’s aptitudes, which were measured by tests and compared with what the occupations required. The counsellor, an expert in psychotechnics, then tried to convince the person that their advice was the right one. Guichard shows that this model assumed stable occupations, which gave people their identity. With it, one understood fairly well how one enters a profession, without knowing anything about what one will do there afterwards. He himself developed another method, which he calls life design counselling dialogue, and which he presents with several colleagues in Concevoir et orienter sa vie (Qui Plus Est, 2017). The counsellor no longer gives an answer: they help the person find their own, starting from what gives meaning to their life.
We adults who are not guidance professionals often advise according to the first model, with fewer tools. We match the person to what we know, that is to say to our own path. And when we tell them to “be realistic”, we pass on to them, without meaning to, what Pierre Bourdieu called the causality of the probable. In “Avenir de classe et causalité du probable” (Revue française de sociologie, 1974), he shows that aspirations tend to adjust to the chances one objectively has. A young person from a working-class background thus often ends up no longer wanting what does not seem meant for them. In Youth as a power relationship, I suggested seeing youth as a role that people are made to play rather than as an age. Career guidance is, in my view, one of the moments when we adults exercise this power most discreetly, with the best intentions in the world.
Immigrants in time
There is another reason to be wary of our ready-made answers, and it has to do with time. Margaret Mead had devoted her life to studying how societies pass on their culture from one generation to the next, from Samoa to New Guinea. After the student revolts of the late 1960s, she published Culture and Commitment (1970), translated into French in 1972 as Le Fossé des générations. In it she calls postfigurative the culture in which children learn from their elders, as was long the case, because the future resembled the past. She saw a prefigurative culture emerging, in which adults must also learn from the young, because the world changes so fast that elders no longer know how to prepare them for what is coming. People born before the Second World War were, in her view, immigrants of a new kind, who had changed eras without changing countries:
“We have moved into a present for which none of us was prepared by our understanding of the past [...] and we are all immigrants in time.”
Margaret Mead, “Culture and Commitment”, 1970.
Some forty years later, Michel Serres read at the Académie française, on 1 March 2011, a text entitled “Petite Poucette. Les nouveaux défis de l’éducation” (Thumbelina: the new challenges of education), which he developed the following year in the book Petite Poucette (Le Pommier, 2012). That is what he called the young people of the time, because of the dexterity with which they send messages with both thumbs, and he linked their difference directly to the transformations of work:
“This immense difference, which affects every language, is due, in part, to the break between the occupations of the fifties and those of today. Thumbelina and her brother will no longer toil at the same tasks.”
Michel Serres, “Petite Poucette. Les nouveaux défis de l’éducation”, 2011 (my translation).
In the book, Thumbelina has all the knowledge in the world in her pocket, on her phone, and Serres drew a consequence for schools, which should first teach her to connect this knowledge and to invent with it. In an interview with Libération in 2015, he poked fun at the “old grumps” who judge young people with their own faculties, without admitting that the brain is transformed by the tools it uses. I extended this reflection in Petite Poucette 2.0, about the moral panic surrounding social media.
I believe that is where we are, and probably even more so than in 1970 or in 2012. I do not know what jobs will look like when today’s high school students are forty, and I know no one who does. With artificial intelligence, whole tasks are passing to machines, and in Artificial Intelligence, Work and Professions I suggested distinguishing, to see more clearly, between the task, the profession, the job and work. That still does not tell me what a person who is seventeen today will be doing in 2050. So I am not the best placed to tell them which training will lead them to a job I do not know, and perhaps they, with their friends, are better placed, since they already live in the world that is coming.
Adults nonetheless have something to offer, and it is not first of all knowledge about jobs. They can offer their listening and their interest in the other person, recognise that person for who they are, and help them say it. That is their role, because they occupy a position as adults, as figures of authority, as educators in the broad sense, and this role does not consist in projecting their own fantasies onto young people. I see it again and again in my work with children and young people, and I have also lived it as a father, with my own children, who became young people and then adults. Jean Guichard, moreover, proposed at the end of the abstract of his 2002 article to replace the central question of guidance, which was to help each person fulfil themselves as a separate individual, with another one:
“[H]ow can we help each person to realise their own humanity by helping others to realise theirs?”
Jean Guichard, “Problématiques et finalités du conseil en orientation”, 2002 (my translation).
Mead also asked adults to listen to those who might know what they do not. In What Teenagers Can Teach Us About Artificial Intelligence, I gave an account of a global conference organised in March 2025 by and for teenagers. It grew out of a question raised two years earlier, at a first symposium on artificial intelligence and education: why were people debating the future of young people without listening to them? For twenty-four hours, it was the teenagers who led the debates and questioned the researchers.
Mead also described a transmission between peers, which she called cofigurative, in which one learns mainly from people of one’s own age, and adults tend to disparage it. A young person who learns to shoot a film with friends, to edit with tutorials, to code by exchanging on a forum, is nonetheless really learning, and often things nobody would have taught them elsewhere. In Young people have not lost their heads, I argue for granting young people a presumption of competence, and career guidance is a good moment to put it into practice: what the person has already learned by themselves, with people at the same stage as them, is part of what they can rely on, and the adult can tell them so.
Starting with what they want
If ready-made answers are not worth much, where should we start? In my view, with a question we ask before answering the one we are asked: what do you feel like doing? Not the job, not the course, but what you enjoy doing, what keeps you busy when nobody asks you to, what you have already tried. Carl Rogers, whom I discussed in The One Who Makes Nothing, believed that each person finds within themselves the means to grow, provided they are given the chance, and he developed this in On Becoming a Person (1961). By asking about what they want, we give the person that chance, and we show them that their desires interest us more than the idea we have of them.
While they answer, the person sometimes lets slip a word of embarrassment, something like “I haven’t done anything yet” or “it’s a bit silly”. We want to reassure them straight away. I think it is better to ask them: why do you say that? What is holding you back? They then start talking about what is really holding them back, which they had said nothing about at the start. We also have to accept the silence that comes before their answer, and that is not easy for an adult. In Receiving, or the difficulty of doing nothing, I told the story of the worry of a youth worker I was training, during the forty-five minutes when young people had gone off to film on their own: she felt that we were not working. In The Thirty Seconds That Belong to Them, I described the anxiety of adults faced with the few seconds pupils took to start speaking during a public presentation, and the temptation to fill that pause for them. In a one-to-one conversation, this temptation seems to me even stronger.
It also happens that the person has already put forward, at some point in the conversation, a way of doing things that suits them: taking a course and practising on the side, waiting a year, starting with an internship, etc. The adult then only has to point it out to them. Telling them “you’re the one who said it, and I think it’s a good way to go about it” strengthens them far more than advice from outside, because the decision remains theirs.
Nose to the phone
Today a young person does a good part of what they enjoy with digital tools, and it is often in this way that they learn on their own. It is also the part of their life that adults know least and judge most quickly. People talk about “screen time”, as if one could know what a person is doing by measuring how long they spend in front of a screen. When I was a child, people worried about children who read all day long, and today they worry about screens, whereas everything depends on what one does with them. I often run workshops in which young people, in pairs, make films with their phones, sometimes in cooperation with artificial intelligences, and we sometimes welcome seventy of them in a cinema. I designed the activity, I gave the demonstration, I know exactly what they are doing. And yet, when I see them for half an hour with their noses to their phones, I feel that nothing is happening, or that something problematic is happening. Then we watch the films, which are astonishingly diverse and inventive. So I carry this preconception myself, and I learn to undo it a little more with each workshop.
I told this story in November 2026, at a talk on young people and digital technology that I gave with Marielle Stinès, now cultural action adviser at the DRAC Normandie (the regional office of the French Ministry of Culture), to professionals from the popular education sector. In 2016 and 2017, with a popular education collective in Poitou-Charentes, she had conducted a survey on young people’s digital practices. The team found that each person cobbles together their own path through digital culture. A teenage girl passionate about cats had thus taught herself HTML in order to develop her own applications. An adult who advises a young person about their studies learns a great deal, from this kind of path, about what they already know how to do and like to do, provided they ask them.
Parents often judge these practices without knowing them, and young people see this clearly. They conclude that their parents are not able to support them. When they run into a problem, online harassment for example, they do not dare talk about it, for fear of being judged wholesale on everything they do online. In Not judging people’s digital practices, I argued that not judging is a condition of mediation, and I came back to it in Banning social media for under-15s. Marielle Stinès gives parents two pieces of advice: take an interest in what your children do with these tools, and create a climate of trust at home, so that a child who runs into a “glitch” can come back to you. Trust is also a condition of learning, as the psychologist Olivier Houdé has shown through his work on cognitive resistance, which I presented in Fear, a learning inhibitor. A guidance conversation depends on it just as much, because a person who is afraid of being judged on what they love will not tell you what they love.
If you are a parent, I suggest opening moments of discussion in which you do not tell your child whether they are right or wrong. You can start from a list of questions to ask them: what are you doing on your phone at the moment? What have you learned on it recently? And when we ask other people questions, it is good to ask them of ourselves. During the talk, I asked the audience to stand up to answer yes to a few questions (who spends more than three hours a day in front of a screen? who has the TikTok app on their phone?), and I stood up with everyone else. An adult who has looked their own habits in the face finds it easier to talk about a young person’s habits without judging them.
Saying where you speak from
Yet there comes a moment when you have to give your opinion, since the person came looking for it. I think it should then be given for what it is, situated knowledge: the point of view of one person, formed in a particular path and in a world that is already no longer quite that of the person listening. In Must You Have Something to Say to Facilitate a Discussion ?, I defended a way of speaking in one’s own name, on an equal footing with others, while keeping a distance from one’s own ideas. In a guidance conversation, I do this with very short phrases: “that’s my opinion”, “others will tell you something else”, “I learned this profession at a time when the tools were not the same”. I have my criteria, like everyone, and I try to deconstruct them as the conversation goes on, which is probably the hardest part; I wrote about this in The question of criteria.
We also have to acknowledge what we do not know. Almost all adults lie to a child one day “for their own good”, often to spare themselves a difficult discussion, and in Taking the Risk of Truth, drawing on Michel Foucault’s parrhesia and on the educator Janusz Korczak, I argued that the child loses part of their trust in adults as a result. Telling a young person “I don’t know if this job will still exist in twenty years, and nobody knows” may seem discouraging. But they, like us, have heard Elon Musk announce that artificial intelligence and robots would replace all jobs (I discussed this statement in Artificial Intelligence, Work and Professions), and they probably sense it already. So I prefer to say it, and in this way I treat them as capable of hearing the truth. We can then look together for the studies that will give them the means to understand the world, and perhaps to invent their own profession in it. When the Forum des images asked me, at the turn of 2004 and 2005, to give cultural meaning to the cameras that were appearing in mobile phones, nobody had been trained for this work, and in The birth of the Pocket Films Festival (2005) I told how we invented it.
From the first question to the next message
To conclude, here are the ways of doing things that I try to keep to myself when a young person asks me for advice. I believe they are also useful for parents, and for everyone who works with young people:
- Ask before answering. Before comparing courses, I ask what the person wants to do and what they have already tried, then I let them finish, even when I think I have understood (Carl Rogers and Richard Farson called this active listening, in 1957).
- Notice signs of embarrassment. “I don’t dare”, “it’s a bit silly”… I ask the person what is holding them back, before telling them they are capable of it, even if I am convinced they are.
- Don’t fill the silences. Twenty or thirty seconds sometimes. I wait, as with a microphone held out to pupils in a room.
- Start again from what the person said. If, in passing, they mentioned taking a course and practising on the side, I remind them that the idea came from them, and I tell them what I think of it.
- Say that it is a point of view. I give my opinion in the first person (“I did it this way, but that was in another world”), and I remind them that other adults will give them other opinions.
- Take seriously what they are already learning. Films shot with friends, tutorials followed in the evening, a website cobbled together in HTML, etc. All of this is part of their education, and I tell them so.
- Ask what they do with their phone. “What do you do on it? What have you learned on it recently?” Without mentioning screen time.
- Ask myself my own questions first. How many hours a day on my own phone, and to do what? That is why I stood up with the audience during the talk.
- Offer to stay in touch. Write to each other from time to time, to share news. They will probably change their mind again for years: in 2025, out of 980,000 candidates registered on Parcoursup, 183,000 were students changing course.