Every new form of moving image was first held to be unworthy: the cinema of peepholes and fairground booths, then television, then series, and today the videos young people watch and make on social media. These forms entered recognised culture because some people, against the current, kept them, showed them and thought about them (Henri Langlois was no doubt the most important of them). I trace this history here, from 1888 to 2026, and I draw one certainty from it: micro-series and films made with artificial intelligence will in turn change status. So what can we do right now in image education, at the very moment when social media are being massively delegitimised?
Before the screen, a peephole
Cinema appears at the end of the nineteenth century, and we often forget that it did not begin with projection on a big screen. In October 1888, in Leeds, England, the French inventor Louis Le Prince filmed a few seconds of his family in a garden with a single-lens camera he had built himself. He is often regarded as the author of the first motion picture camera, but he disappeared in 1890 on a train between Dijon and Paris, and his work had no sequel. A few years earlier, in 1882, the physiologist Étienne-Jules Marey had developed a photographic gun to break down the flight of birds. In Thomas Edison’s laboratory in West Orange, New Jersey, William Kennedy Laurie Dickson built a camera at the beginning of the 1890s, the kinetograph, together with the viewer that went with it, the kinetoscope.
The strip kinetograph, the camera of Edison’s laboratory. Photograph Thomas Edison National Historical Park, public domain.
The film stock was Dickson’s doing too. He received flexible film from Eastman, had it cut into strips 35 millimetres wide (one and three-eighths of an inch, in the measures of the time), and had four small holes punched on each side of each frame, where the teeth of the camera caught to pull the film along, frame after frame. Edison wanted this format for himself alone. He defended it as his patent until 1902, when an American court ruled against him. In 1909, 35 mm with four perforations became the international standard. We shot and projected films on this medium throughout the twentieth century, right up to digital!
A 35 mm negative, with four perforations on each side of the frame. Photograph Runner1616, CC BY-SA 3.0 licence.
The first place where people paid to see films: a shop in New York, at 1155 Broadway, opened by the Holland brothers on 14 April 1894. Kinetoscopes in a row, big wooden cabinets. You leaned over the peephole, alone, and watched a film a few dozen seconds long running in a loop. The small individual screen therefore came before the large projection we associate with cinema. But what did people watch in these boxes? And what did others think of it?
A kinetoscope parlour in San Francisco, around 1894-1895. Unknown photographer, public domain.
Dancers, boxers and a kiss
Among the first films shot in March 1894 in the Black Maria, Edison’s studio, there is Carmencita, a Spanish dancer who was then a triumph in New York music halls. The historian Charles Musser believes she was the first woman ever filmed in the United States. Her film was also one of the first to be withdrawn. In Asbury Park, New Jersey, a man complained to the mayor because the dance showed the dancer’s legs, and the mayor had the film replaced by one of two boxing cats.
The Black Maria, the first film studio, built in 1893 in West Orange. Photograph attributed to William Kennedy Laurie Dickson, public domain.
In September 1894, Edison had a fight filmed between the boxers James Corbett and Peter Courtney. The fight was cut into rounds, each watched in a separate machine, ten cents a round, sixty cents for the whole fight, at a time when prize fights were banned in many American states. In 1896, a Coney Island dancer known as Fatima was filmed performing a belly dance, and some prints circulated with white bars painted over her hips and chest. The same year, The Kiss, in which the actors May Irwin and John C. Rice re-enact the kiss from a Broadway comedy, caused a scandal. A Chicago literary magazine wrote at the time:
“Magnified to Gargantuan proportions and repeated three times over it is absolutely disgusting.”
“The Chap-Book”, Chicago, 1896.
The same text considered that this kind of spectacle was a matter for the police.
We often read that people watched stripteases in kinetoscopes. Historical research invites us to be more precise. What people mostly saw were music-hall dancers whose movements were considered indecent, and undressing films, such as Trapeze Disrobing Act, shot by the Edison company in 1901, came a little later, and a writer had announced them as early as 1896. In July of that year, the Russian writer Maxim Gorky saw the Lumière films at the Nizhny Novgorod fair, in Charles Aumont’s café-concert, a place of paid pleasures. In the review he published on 4 July, he predicted that these views of families and landscapes would soon be replaced by scenes more in keeping with the taste of the place, and he imagined their titles, a woman undressing, a lady in her bath.
The kinetoscope’s bad reputation, I believe, came as much from the box as from what you saw inside it. To see Corbett and Courtney to the end, you had to go from one machine to the next, six times, ten cents each time, bent over the peephole, among a mostly male public who came to see alone what they would probably not have watched with their families. Those who despised these films despised this public too. Pierre Bourdieu gave this mechanism a famous formula in Distinction in 1979: “taste classifies, and it classifies the classifier”. Fourteen years earlier, he had directed Photography: A Middle-brow Art, a survey of family photography among the working classes, which was regarded as a practice without artistic value. And I do not exclude myself. My judgements on images also say something about the place I occupy, and it is about my own tastes that I find it hardest to see: with a series by David Lynch, for example, it took me twenty-five years.
The Bazar de la Charité and the fairground booths
In France, the Lumière brothers’ cinématographe, both camera and projector, was presented to the public on 28 December 1895, in Paris, in the Salon indien of the Grand Café. For the first time, spectators watched films projected onto a screen together. The cinématographe very quickly met with the same suspicion as the kinetoscope, with fear added to it.
Henri Brispot’s poster for the Cinématographe Lumière, 1895-1896. Public domain.
On 4 May 1897, the fire at the Bazar de la Charité killed one hundred and twenty-six people, most of them aristocratic women who had come to a charity sale. The fire started from the ether lamp lighting the projection of a cinématographe, and for a long time the public associated cinema with danger. For about ten years in France, it was mostly fairground showmen who showed films, in booths set up between the merry-go-rounds and the menageries, for a working-class public who paid little. In this fairground cinema, which made little money and from which cultivated circles turned away, women were numerous, and Alice Guy made La Fée aux choux there, one of the very first fiction films.
The Bazar de la Charité fire on the cover of the illustrated supplement of Le Petit Journal, 16 May 1897. Public domain.
At the time, nobody thought these films deserved to be kept for us, who would come after. Exhibitors wore them out and sold them on by the metre. Others recovered the silver contained in the film emulsion. And nitrate prints burst into flames at the slightest spark.
Borrowing the legitimacy of theatre
The first attempts to rid cinema of this reputation came from inside the industry. In 1908, the Film d’Art company produced L’Assassinat du duc de Guise, written by the academician Henri Lavedan, with actors from the Comédie-Française and an original score by Camille Saint-Saëns. The film was presented in Paris on 17 November 1908 to a select audience. The founders of the Film d’Art wanted to draw the bourgeoisie to the cinema by offering it what it already recognised, theatre and art music. In short, they borrowed their legitimacy from the already consecrated arts: cinema became respectable, on condition that it imitated.
Ricciotto Canudo, an Italian writer living in Paris, took another path. In 1911, he published a text entitled “The Birth of a Sixth Art”. He spoke of the “seventh art” from 1919 onwards, and in 1921 he founded the Club des amis du septième art, one of the first film clubs. For him, cinema had nothing to borrow; it was a new art that brought together the arts of space and the arts of time. He also saw, very early on, that the word “art” had become a promotional tool, and he wrote so in his manifesto:
“If the countless and baneful shopkeepers of cinema thought they could appropriate the word ’Seventh Art’, which immediately raised the standing of their industry and their trade, they did not accept the responsibility imposed by the word: Art.”
Ricciotto Canudo, “Manifesto of the Seven Arts”, 1923.
Canudo wrote that in 1923. You can seize the prestige of a word without taking on any of the demands it carries: that has not aged a day! For him, legitimising cinema meant taking seriously what images can do, and the merchants who stuck “art” on their posters could not have cared less.
Seven years later, in 1930, Georges Duhamel came back from the United States and published Scènes de la vie future, in which cinema becomes an entertainment for illiterate people worn out by work, an effortless spectacle that gives rise to no thought at all. Walter Benjamin read this passage closely, since he quoted it a few years later in The Work of Art in the Age of Its Technological Reproducibility. For Benjamin, it was the same old complaint against the masses: they supposedly seek distraction instead of contemplating works of art. Except that Benjamin, instead of lamenting with Duhamel, takes this distraction seriously, and sees in it a new way of perceiving, which spectators learn precisely at the cinema.
Henri Langlois and his parents’ bathtub
At the end of the 1920s, sound arrived, and nobody wanted silent films any more. The owners of the prints got rid of them en masse: they took up space, they could catch fire, the silver could be recovered from the emulsion, and in any case nobody thought they were worth anything. Henri Langlois, born in 1914, was not yet twenty when he started collecting them, at the beginning of the 1930s, and Agnès Varda recounted that he stacked them in his parents’ bathtub, right up to the ceiling! In 1936, with Georges Franju and Jean Mitry, he founded the Cinémathèque française.
Langlois wanted to keep everything, and I find that very beautiful. His assistant Jacques Richard put it this way: save the masterpiece, the unknown film, even the fascist films. Agnès Varda remembered that he also wanted people to keep the films they did not like. He distrusted, I believe, our criteria of the moment, the ones with which we judge works without the slightest idea of what they will become.
He kept them, but in order to show them. Lotte Eisner, who worked with him, reported his conviction: a film is like a person, it needs to go out for a walk, and if you leave it in a cellar, it dies. Under the Occupation, he organised clandestine screenings of films banned by the Nazis. Simone Signoret recalled seeing Battleship Potemkin that way, in the small dining room of Langlois’s mother, who served little pink cakes, at a time when you could go to prison for having seen that film! After the war, at Langlois’s, a single evening could run a Soviet silent film into a western, then a slapstick comedy into a German expressionist film. No announced hierarchy. Truffaut and Godard, among others, learned cinema that way.
Several of these young spectators became critics, then filmmakers. The Cahiers du cinéma, founded in 1951 by André Bazin, Jacques Doniol-Valcroze and Joseph-Marie Lo Duca, published Truffaut’s text “A Certain Tendency of French Cinema” in January 1954, from which what came to be called the auteur policy emerged. Hitchcock, Hawks? For the serious criticism of the time, makers of Hollywood entertainment, nothing more. The Cahiers made them auteurs, in the sense in which one speaks of a writer. Do you see the difference with the Film d’Art, which imitated theatre to gain respect? These young people looked very closely at what everyone despised, and found in it a thinking through images.
We often forget that the history of cinema, the one we were taught, was written with the films that had been kept. In February 1968, André Malraux’s ministry removed Langlois from the head of the Cinémathèque; filmmakers took to the streets, and Langlois got his post back in April, seventy-five days later. But according to the Cinémathèque française itself, only a fifth of the films produced between 1895 and 1930 survive today. Charlie Chaplin’s films survived first of all because they had been successful. The rest disappeared before anyone wondered what it was worth.
It also took a long time for silent cinema to be taken seriously again. As a teenager, at the beginning of the 1950s, the British historian Kevin Brownlow became passionate about these films, and his friends advised him not to waste his time with pictures they found “jerky, poorly photographed and ludicrously badly acted”. He went to meet the Hollywood pioneers who were still alive, and in 1968 he published The Parade’s Gone By, a history of silent cinema made of their testimonies. He then devoted decades to reconstructing Abel Gance’s Napoléon. His conviction is that we despise silent cinema because we have never seen it in good prints, projected at the right speed, with music, and therefore that our judgement also depends on the conditions in which we see films.
The small screen, then series
With television, the roles were reversed: now it was film people who looked down on it. Cinephiles said that the small screen spoiled films, cut by advertising, reduced, watched with half an eye in a living room. For a long time, this kept us from seeing what television had produced that was remarkable, for example the programmes Pierre Schaeffer and his teams designed for the ORTF. And in 1996, in On Television, Pierre Bourdieu still described it as an instrument that subjects thought to the ratings.
Series followed the same path, faster. When David Lynch created Twin Peaks in 1990, a recognised filmmaker came to television, and it was his signature that made the series watchable in the eyes of the critics. For me, that was not enough at all. I already loved David Lynch, I had adored Eraserhead, his first feature film, which I had waited several years to be able to see in a cinema, at eighteen. When the series Twin Peaks came out, I had no desire to watch it, and I did not watch it. In 1992, I went to see Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me, the cinema film Lynch made about what happens before the series, and it became one of Lynch’s most important films for me, perhaps my favourite. I still did not watch the series. It was in 2017, when Lynch made a third season, twenty-five years later, that I watched the three seasons one after the other. It took me twenty-five years to allow myself to watch a series by a filmmaker I admired, because it was a series.
Then came The Sopranos, on HBO, in 1999, and with them the showrunner: people began to speak of the person who writes and directs a series from one season to the next as an auteur. In France, the Séries Mania festival was created in 2010 at the Forum des images. This is the Paris institution where the Pocket Films Festival had been born in 2005, at a time when films shot with phones were not regarded as cinema. And today? Series are studied at university, they have their festivals, their prizes, and nobody apologises any more for liking them.
For cinema, the boundary simply moved. In 2017, Netflix had two films in competition at the Cannes Film Festival, Okja by Bong Joon-ho and The Meyerowitz Stories by Noah Baumbach. After the controversy, the festival decided that from 2018 onwards, a film could only compete if it was released in French cinemas. We still attach legitimacy to the cinema hall and to the feature film, and for decades 35 mm film served as a barrier between professional cinema and everything else.
Social media videos, micro-series and generated films
Today, it is social media videos. What young people watch on TikTok, Instagram or YouTube, what they post there: we consider it worthless, and often dangerous. In August 2020, a ten-second video by Bella Poarch, in which she makes faces to the song “M to the B”, passed 400 million views in a month. On 21 July 2026, the French Parliament adopted a law banning social media for under-fifteens. Since 1 September, platforms are no longer allowed to open an account for a young person of that age, and existing accounts must be closed before 1 January 2027. Australia had done so in December 2025, for under-sixteens. Members of Parliament want to protect the health of children and teenagers, and I am not discussing these laws here. I simply note that they come with a very broad cultural delegitimisation of what young people watch and make, and that it closely resembles the one the kinetoscope went through.
I am thinking in particular of two forms. First, micro-series, micro-dramas: fictions in episodes of one or two minutes, filmed vertically for the phone, bought episode by episode, with stories of revenge, love and social payback. In China, this market was worth 50.44 billion yuan in 2024, more than all the country’s cinemas that same year! In the United States, it passed a billion dollars in 2025, and in January 2026 TikTok launched an app just for them, PineDrama. And then films made with artificial intelligence: the festival that the company Runway devotes to them received around three hundred films in 2023, and around six thousand in 2025, twenty times more in two years.
What do we reproach these forms with? Micro-series supposedly have repetitive plots, heavy-handed acting, crude tricks, and generated images are called slop. When I hear that, I hear what people said about the kinetoscope in 1894. And look at the devices: a small screen for a single person, very short films, subjects designed to keep that person in front of their device. It is almost the same thing! Vertical films and films made with artificial intelligence have their own language. It is obvious to me that micro-series, and even things made with artificial intelligence, will little by little take on different statuses, that works will be recognised within them, that authors will emerge from them, and that their history will one day be taught. That is a certainty. What I do not know is how this legitimation will happen, nor what we will have lost by then.
Doing as Langlois did, with young people
From this history, I draw five proposals, which I put into practice myself or make to the teachers, librarians and mediators I train.
The first is to watch with young people what they watch, before judging. With the criteria we were taught, which were made for older forms, we inevitably miss what new forms invent. So why not put a micro-series on the projector, watch it to the end with the class, and then ask the pupils what they found in it? I already call that an image education session, and often one of the liveliest there is.
Next, keeping, as Langlois did, including images that their authors find of no interest. This autumn, in Grenoble, I led a morning session with some twenty mediators and managers of travelling cinemas from the Ligue de l’enseignement. I asked them who had a photo of their venue or of a screening on their phone, and almost nobody raised a hand. One participant ended up saying that her images were of no interest: “it’s a person in front of an audience and a screen behind”. So I opened a shared folder, which I called “Traces”, and within a few minutes there were nearly thirty photos in it: village halls full of plastic chairs, a screen stretched across a meadow at nightfall, an old projector... Micro-series and films made with artificial intelligence are even more fragile. A micro-series that no longer makes money disappears from the app overnight, and workshop films stay on participants’ phones, where nobody can find them three months later. Our memory is fragile, it sleeps on the platforms’ servers. What prevents a library, a media library or an image education organisation from building collections of them right now, with their documentation? The day their value is recognised, we will be very glad to have them.
Let us also tell pupils the history of contempt itself! You show Carmencita and The Kiss, then an episode of a micro-series, and you read aloud what was written in 1896, then what is written in 2026. Pupils do not need a lecture to see that a value judgement has a date, and that it comes from somewhere in society. With secondary school pupils, the mediators of Immersion VR, in the Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes region, start with the history of the medium since the kinetoscope, and the virtual reality headset only comes afterwards.
There is the device, too. A small individual screen calls for very fast plots, in 1894 as in 2026, and I find it fascinating to look for the reasons with pupils. You watch lying on your bed or sitting in a cinema, alone or with others, on a six-inch screen or a ten-metre one, for one minute or two hours: all this affects what images show, and once you have understood it, you no longer watch in quite the same way.
And finally, making things with these forms. In 2005, when we created the Pocket Films Festival with the Forum des images, some people found the idea absurd: to make films, there were cameras! I answered that in ten years’ time, everyone would have a camera in their pocket. In 2024, again at the Forum des images, 350 teenagers from Tumo Paris made films with artificial intelligences, in eight sessions in a cinema auditorium. For my part, it has always been by making things that I understood what a form allowed and what it prevented, and that is where I formed my own idea of it, free of prejudice.
This is what I take from Langlois. Nobody had asked him to keep silent cinema, and he did not ask himself whether it was art. He kept, he showed, and others, after him, were able to recognise what he had saved. In image education, we can hold that place today, alongside the forms we find unworthy, by keeping them, and by making them with the young people who already watch them.





