In museums and exhibitions, videos often loop on screens. This can be very beautiful: a painting also stays on the wall all day, and a video installed in a room of its own, with a label and a bench, is watched like an artwork. But you can also do something else with a video. You can replace it with another one from one day to the next, and a computer can start it on its own at the time you have chosen. I suggest also using this possibility to programme a museum the way you programme a cinema: times when the film is shown on a big screen, a different film every day, and, after some screenings, a conversation among the people who watched it together.
Videos playing on a loop
I have often installed looping videos, and I like what they make possible. Nobody needs to be there to start them, and people catch them midway, whenever they arrive, for as long as they like. In 2017, at the Paul Langevin secondary school in Mitry-Mory, we projected the films shot with a drone during the ongoing workshop on a loop in the entrance hall, so that the workshop would concern everyone, including the pupils who were not taking part (Town of Mitry-Mory : drone workshop at Paul Langevin College). The same year, at the Filmer le travail festival in Poitiers, photographs accompanied by a text written by passers-by were projected on a loop on site, to make others want to take part (Poitiers film festival : writing workshop « Écrits sur Images »). In both cases, the loop had a clear function, and people knew what they were watching: what had just been made, here, by people like them.
A video, like a painting, needs to be given a place in the room, and its sound needs to be set so that it can be heard without disturbing the neighbouring rooms; a label, with the title and length, also helps people know what they are watching.
A loop installed like an artwork
A video that plays all day can hold its place in a room like a painting on the wall, depending on how it is installed. In 2022, I showed films in “Loop”, a group exhibition at the Lyon Particule gallery where five artists brought together by Laurent Antonczak presented looping animated images (« Loop » : collective exhibition (Lyon Particule Gallery)). My films played on a large projection and on a small screen, and each of the two had its label, with the title and length of each film. Visitors could also photograph the exhibition, and photograph themselves in it, then share their pictures thanks to a QR code on the wall. People came to see these films the way they come to see paintings, at whatever time they liked, without waiting for a screening.
The film theorist Dominique Païni, who directed the Cinémathèque française and curated many exhibitions about cinema, notes in “Pourquoi expose-t-on le cinéma ?” (“Why exhibit cinema?”, 24 images, no. 140, 2008) that exhibited cinema rivals painting thanks to loop projection, made endless by the digital disc. He speaks of “the affirmation of the sequence as a painting, but a painting made of passing duration, made with time” (my translation of « l’affirmation de la séquence comme tableau, mais un tableau fait de durée qui s’écoule, fait avec du temps »).
The cinema and the exhibition room
The critic Raymond Bellour, a researcher at the CNRS since 1964 who founded the journal Trafic with Serge Daney in 1991, has written a great deal about this difference. In 2012 he gathered his texts on the subject in La Querelle des dispositifs, published by P.O.L, and there he defends the screening: “The lived projection of a film in a cinema, in the dark, during the prescribed time of a more or less collective screening, has become and remains the condition of a unique experience of perception and memory […]” (my translation of « La projection vécue d’un film en salle, dans le noir, le temps prescrit d’une séance plus ou moins collective, est devenue et reste la condition d’une expérience unique de perception et de mémoire »). In an exhibition, the visitor comes and goes as they please, and decides for themselves how long to stay in front of the image. Bellour holds on to what is unique about the screening, and he is wary of those who confuse it today with the exhibition.
Dominique Païni sees things differently. In his 2008 text, he writes that cinema in the museum brings “the widening of the visitor’s position to that of the spectator”, and adds: “Positions that add up and combine” (my translation of « l’élargissement de la position du visiteur à celle de spectateur » and « Positions qui s’ajoutent et se conjuguent »). So you do not have to be one or the other: you can be both, one after the other!
On this point, I feel closer to Païni than to Bellour, while understanding what Bellour defends. Why not, in a museum, let a video loop from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. for whoever passes by, and also project it on a big screen at 3 p.m., in front of a few chairs, for twenty minutes? At 3 p.m., it is a screening, with a beginning and an end, which people watch together, and yet it is the same film as the one you saw in passing at noon.
You don’t change a painting every morning
In a museum, nobody takes down the paintings every morning to hang others: a new hang is a new exhibition, with months of preparation, transport, insurance, etc. With video, it is quite another matter! To change the film, you just copy a file, and the time at which it plays is set once and for all, for example like this: at 10 a.m., a programmable plug (you can find one for around ten euros in any DIY shop) switches the screen on; at 11 a.m., the computer opens the first film (on Windows, the Task Scheduler takes care of this, and other systems have their equivalent); at 3 p.m., it opens the second; at 6 p.m., the plug cuts the power. Many projectors can also be set to start as soon as they are powered. This is what we did in 2022 in the waiting room of the hospital in Flers: the large wall lights up on its own every morning, images of nature are projected on it all day, and it switches off in the evening without anyone having to think about it (« On the beach of my imagination » : video installation in the hospital).
All that remains is to write the “schedule”, like those of cinemas, and put it up at the entrance: one film at 11 a.m., another at 3 p.m., and why not a third on Saturday at 6 p.m. The screenings take place even on days when the whole team is busy elsewhere. The museum thus has its appointments every day, for the price of a programmable plug and a computer it often already had. I hardly know a cheaper way of organising events when you have neither the budget nor the staff to do so every week.
In 2011, at the Festival de Liège, “Fast Movies” presented films shot with mobile phones, chosen from the collections I had built up (Fast Movies au Festival de Liège). For twenty-six evenings, in the space called “Les Écuries”, a programme looped on a double-sided screen stretched across the middle of the room, and thirteen thematic programmes were each shown twice. Anyone who came back on another evening saw other films.
At a set time, on the big screen
In July 2019, at EP7, the digital guinguette set up near the Bibliothèque nationale de France, a selection of my drone films was shown on the venue’s ten screens, as an eighteen-minute loop, during an evening announced from 7 p.m. to 9 p.m. (EP7 The digital dance hall). The films were looping, and yet people came to see them at a given time and place, as for a screening.
In an exhibition that lasts several days, you can do much the same thing without great resources. You let the video loop on a small screen or a computer, and you write in the programme that at such a time, on such a day, it will be projected on a big screen. At that time, you set up a projector, put out a few chairs or cushions on the floor, dim the lights if you can, and for twenty minutes this corner of the room becomes a small cinema. If people come, they sit down and watch the film together. Writing it in the programme is often enough to establish the moment: people come at that time because they read that at that time, something was happening.
A large museum can do this on another scale. For the exhibition “Enfin le cinéma !” at the musée d’Orsay, from September 2021 to January 2022, Dominique Païni, its chief curator, had selected excerpts from early films, shown on a large screen in the museum’s nave.
A film a day, written in the programme
You can also change the film every day. Instead of a single video playing throughout the exhibition, you choose several, and each one has its day, shown in the programme: Monday, this film, Tuesday, that one, etc. People can watch it whenever they like during the day, for five minutes or in full.
With this very modest change, the video changes status. It becomes a proposal that is owned, with its date and title, chosen by someone for that day, instead of a piece of decor set down once and for all. The person in charge of the exhibition, for their part, can feel they are bringing a new proposal every day, even outside the highlights, just by changing the video. And the programme gains in variety: people who come only for the opening evening see that something else happens on the other days, and those who live nearby have a reason to come back.
I believe this programme is better sent by name to people you know than broadcast widely. In The connected audience I argued that attendance depends less on communication than on the bonds woven between people and proposals; a PDF of the full programme, sent by each participant to their own contacts with a couple of personal words, often reaches more people than a general announcement.
Staying to talk after the 3 p.m. film
When the screening is over, the people who have just watched the same film, sitting side by side, do not know each other, but they have seen the same thing at the same moment. I suggest giving them the opportunity to talk about it, even when nobody from the team is there to facilitate.
It takes very little: a question written on a card left on the chairs, or posted next to the screen, about the film rather than about what one ought to think of it (“What surprised you?”, “Which moment stayed with you?”), a little time before the next screening, and a table to sit at. Some people will leave, and that is fine; those who want to will stay and talk among themselves. You can also invite them to leave a trace of what they said to each other, on a large sheet on the wall or through a QR code leading to a sharing space, as in the “Loop” exhibition.
In Becoming a public I suggested talking about the codes of a cultural venue while people are experiencing them, so that visitors become a public in John Dewey’s sense: people who are concerned by the same thing and start talking about it together. With a screening followed by a question, at a set time, the opportunity arises every day, and it costs nothing more than the card. I don’t know whether the conversation will take off at every screening, but it seems to me enough that it happens from time to time for people who did not know each other to have spoken in that museum.
Small image, big sound
Another way of making video exist in the space is through sound. You can keep the image small, on the screen of a computer placed on a table, and play the sound throughout the room. This small image with a big sound creates a very particular intimacy: you hear the film before you see it, you come closer, and you find yourself with a few others leaning over a tiny screen while the sound fills the whole room.
In L’Audio-vision (1990), Michel Chion calls “added value” the expressive and informative contribution of sound to an image, a contribution such that it seems to come from the image itself. In Voice first I described the importance of sound in video workshops, and the same holds in an exhibition: a video whose sound is cut so as not to disturb loses much of what could hold people’s attention, whereas with well-diffused sound, even with a modest image, they come closer.
Soundscapes also have their place in an exhibition, independently of any image. In 2024, during a training course on creating a photography exhibition at the Institut pour la photographie, I asked each teacher to record with their phone a soundscape of at least five minutes, so that it could be played on a loop in the exhibition we were going to build together (Multidisciplinary photographic exhibition creation workshop).
A computer, headphones, a label
When you want people to watch a film in full, in a place where other things are going on, the most economical option is often an ordinary laptop on a small table, with headphones, two chairs, and a small label giving the film’s title, its length and the names of those who made it. You dress the station up a little, with a piece of fabric or a lamp, so that it does not look like a desk, and the computer becomes a viewing place.
A few details matter a great deal. One pair of headphones per person, so that everyone watches in their own bubble and people do not disturb each other by talking. Each station in its own corner, against a wall where the label can go, rather than several computers lined up one behind the other as in a computer room. And two stations are often enough; there is no need to overdo it.
It also seems useful to me to separate the spaces. At the entrance to an exhibition, for example, you can set aside one area for presenting and selling books or objects, and another, quieter one for watching and reading. When you move from one to the other, you understand that you are changing activity, and if you see on entering that here, you come to watch, you settle down in front of a film more readily. In Prenez des feutres et prenez une table I described how a name written on a table helps people know where they are; a viewing station gains a lot from being named in the same way.
Points not to miss
- I decide what I expect from the video. In Mitry-Mory, the loop in the hall made the workshop known; in Lyon, in “Loop”, my films were artworks; at EP7, they had a schedule. These are three different set-ups.
- When the loop is an artwork, I install it as an artwork. In “Loop”, the large projection and the small screen each had their label, with the titles and lengths of the films.
- I write the video into the programme. With its title and date, and, if the film changes every day, the film of the day.
- I set a schedule on the computer. Over twenty-six evenings, in Liège in 2011, thirteen programmes followed one another, each shown twice; a computer and a programmable plug make it possible to do the same in a museum, with nobody needed to press the button.
- I set times when the film is shown on a big screen. In 2019, the EP7 evening had a schedule, from 7 p.m. to 9 p.m., written in the programme. To do the same in a museum, a projector and a few chairs are enough.
- I leave a question on the chairs after the screening. “Which moment stayed with you?”, for example, handwritten on a card. Nobody is obliged to answer; those who wish stay and talk about it, without a facilitator.
- I take care of the sound. When you cut a video’s sound so as not to disturb, you take away what could hold people’s attention; I prefer a small image with a big sound, and soundscapes like those of the Institut pour la photographie in 2024.
- I set up simple stations, each in its own corner. Two stations are often enough: for each, a laptop, two pairs of headphones, two chairs, a label, and a piece of fabric on the table (so that it does not look like an “office”).
- I separate the areas. The books being presented or sold stay at the entrance, and people watch and read further in, in peace.
- I send the programme by name. Rather than a general announcement, each participant sends the PDF to their own contacts, with a couple of personal words, as I suggest in “The connected audience”.