Inquiring in the spirit of cultural rights

Territorial diagnoses, evaluations, dissertations, theses. So that the way we study a cultural situation puts into practice the cultural rights it takes as its object, and how to go about it.

12 September 2026 Benoît Labourdette  14 min

A territorial diagnosis, an evaluation or a dissertation is about people, about their practices and about what they say. When we claim to work in the name of cultural rights, we have to bring them to life in our method, and not only describe them. I start again from what an inquiry is for John Dewey, I add to his definition what I have learned from practitioners of cultural urbanism and ecology, and I draw from all this eight gestures within reach of a student as much as of an agency, from writing down what troubles us to giving the work back to the people concerned.

Inquiry rather than research

When John Dewey published his great book on logic in 1938, he chose “inquiry” as its central concept. His French translator, Gérard Deledalle, who brought out Logique. La théorie de l’enquête with the Presses universitaires de France in 1967, explains that he set aside the French word “recherche” (research) because it calls to mind too strongly the experimental technique of laboratories, which in his eyes is one particular case of inquiry and not its model. For Dewey, inquiry begins when a person finds themselves in an indeterminate, troubled situation, where they no longer know how to act, and inquiring consists in transforming that situation into a determinate one, where it is possible to act again. The person who inquires does not look down on the situation from above, but is part of it. And inquiry does not belong to scholars: the gardener faced with a plant that is wasting away, the team faced with a project that is going nowhere, are inquiring too. In the article John Dewey : an inspirer of cultural rights ? I presented the kinship between this philosophy and cultural democracy.

Dewey had given inquiry its political dimension eleven years earlier, in The Public and Its Problems (1927). A public, he writes there, does not exist in advance; it forms when people realise that an action they did not decide has consequences for their lives, and they start talking about it, looking together for where the trouble comes from and how to get out of it. Against Walter Lippmann, who wanted to entrust common affairs to experts, Dewey maintains, in his chapter on method, that the person who wears the shoe knows better than anyone that it pinches and where it pinches, even if the shoemaker remains the best judge of how to remedy it. Joëlle Zask, his French translator, sums up this position by speaking of the public as a community of inquirers. I take three things from it:

  • an inquiry begins with a trouble that is felt, and not with a question drawn up in an office;
  • it is the people affected by the situation who lead the inquiry, with the help of specialists if need be, and not the other way round;
  • what has been learned is used to transform the situation, otherwise what was done was a description, not an inquiry.

To what Dewey says I add a distinction of my own, between the expert and the intellectual. The expert has a commissioning client, and cannot call the commission into question: the object is given, the conclusions cannot go beyond what the client is ready to hear, and the bias is structural, however honest the person may be. The intellectual, for their part, chooses their object and answers for their conclusions before anyone who wishes to discuss them. Those who inquire on their own account, a gardener, a resident, a team, inquire into a situation they care deeply about, which gives them other biases: attachment, anger, fear, hope. But those biases can be named, because they are their own, whereas the expert has to keep theirs quiet. In the article The Simulacrum of Presence I argued for an openly assumed subjectivity rather than a façade of objectivity; inquiry led by the people concerned is its collective form.

In France, this idea has a history, which runs through Cerisy, where the conference “Transformations des politiques culturelles” (Transformations of cultural policies) was held from 18 to 24 June 2026. I drew from it the lexicon « Careful, it’s slippery », and I rely here on several of the talks I heard there. Paul Desjardins, the founder of the Décades de Pontigny, of which the Cerisy conferences are the heirs, opened in 1913 the École de commune culture (School of common culture), intended for adults already at work, with no diploma required. People learned there through contact with reality and through direct inquiry, by going to question those who practised a trade, guided not by professors but by “conducteurs d’études” (study leaders). The war interrupted the experiment after one year. I recall it because Desjardins already held that a common culture is built by exploring the world together, and not by handing down to the people a culture held by a few.

Today we call “inquiry” (or “survey”, the same word in French: enquête) three things which, in Dewey’s sense, are not inquiries, or not yet:

  • The expert diagnosis. Someone comes from outside to observe, measure and conclude, then leaves. The trouble in question is not that of the people but that of the client, and the situation remains the same as before, with one more document.
  • The questionnaire and the opinion poll. In the article Are Polls and Surveys Objective ? I showed how far the questions are decided elsewhere and how far those who write them thereby steer the answers, and in the article Giving Ourselves Permission to Create I recalled, on the basis of the collective volume Les données de l’enquête, whose authors draw on Dewey and on Harold Garfinkel, that a piece of data does not exist outside the process through which it is produced.
  • The collection of good practices. It gathers examples reputed to be transposable, whereas transposing them supposes a work of translation that is absent from the fact sheet.

These three forms have their uses, and they can be employed within an inquiry as tools among others, provided they do not stand in for it.

The people concerned are already analysts

In classical sociology, analysis fell to the researcher alone: people were questioned, then their answers were interpreted on the basis of a knowledge they did not share. Against this posture Harold Garfinkel built ethnomethodology, set out in Studies in Ethnomethodology (1967). In it he refuses to regard the members of a society as passive executors of rules that are beyond them. People constantly deploy methods, fine-grained and largely tacit, to produce their social situations and make them intelligible, and the researcher’s work consists in describing those methods, instead of pressing their own onto lives they know less well than those who live them.

The anthropologist Tim Ingold extends this movement when he defines his discipline as “philosophy with the people in”. In Anthropology and/as Education (Routledge, 2018), he contrasts the transmission of content with an education understood as attention paid to the world and to others, and in a 2014 article with a deliberately blunt title, “That’s enough about ethnography!”, he distinguishes ethnography, which describes people in order to report their world to others, from anthropology, which learns with them. To inquire with someone, in this sense, comes down to standing beside them, looking at what they are looking at, and accepting that what they know unsettles what we thought we knew, rather than collecting their words to analyse them later without them.

This position meets an observation I often make: cultural facts exist with or without cultural policies, with or without funding. People sing, film, dance, tell their stories, pass things on, within instituted settings or outside any setting. The people who live these practices are their first analysts, in Garfinkel’s sense. The urbanist Maud Le Floc’h, founder of POLAU, a centre for arts and urbanism, speaks of a “permanent knitting together” of “knowing knowledge”, sensitive knowledge and situated knowledge, those of specialists, those of artists and those of the people who inhabit a place, and she sees in the separation of the sensitive and the technical, on which a good part of French cultural policy was founded, the thing that now has to be undone. An inquiry consistent with cultural rights therefore starts from lived situations and from the traces people keep of them or agree to produce, and those who lead it work out the analysis with these people, rather than about them.

Yet the questionnaire remains, by far, the most widespread tool. They are produced endlessly, on every subject, the cultural practices of a territory, satisfaction after a show, the needs of a network, and even in master’s dissertations, and this is called an inquiry. I suggest asking three questions of every questionnaire:

  • Is it an inquiry? In Dewey’s sense, only if a trouble lies at the origin of the questions and if the answers are used to transform the situation. A questionnaire sent out because a funding scheme requires it, processed, summarised in a report, meets neither of these conditions.
  • What place as contributors is given to the people questioned? In most cases, none: they are sources. They did not write the questions, they will not see the other answers, they will take no part in what is drawn from them. Their words are extracted, and then belong to others.
  • What do people gain from it afterwards in terms of power to act? Most often nothing, and sometimes worse: answering questionnaires whose effect one never sees teaches that speaking up is pointless, and that is a lesson people remember.

I do not conclude from this that the questionnaire should be given up. It makes it possible to see in a certain way, on a large scale, and in the Perche region, a questionnaire that nobody knew what to do with nonetheless brought to light the massive practice of hiking, from which everything started again. But this way of seeing has to be chosen knowingly, not out of habit, and if it is used within an inquiry, the people questioned must be able to help write its questions, read its results and discuss how they are used. Otherwise it is an extraction, and the word inquiry serves as its dressing.

The pebble in the shoe

Practitioners of ecology and cultural urbanism have led me to revisit the definition of inquiry on a question Dewey does not develop: who feels the initial trouble, and how it gets put into words. In Où atterrir ? (La Découverte, 2017; in English Down to Earth), Bruno Latour proposed an exercise, which I presented in the article Building Co-Resilience: describing one’s dwelling place, that is, drawing up the inventory of what we depend on to subsist and of who depends on us. Latour and those who ran the “Où atterrir ?” workshops with him then gave this exercise the form of a compass, a diagram with two axes that each person fills in from their own situation, heritage on one side and the future on the other, allies on one side and threats on the other, placing entities all the closer to oneself the more hold one has on them.

Élisabeth Taudière, architect and director of Territoires pionniers, the Maison de l’architecture of Normandy, trained in this tool in 2024, and tells in four scenes the inquiry it has enabled her to lead. She begins with her water bill, in Caen, where she reads in large type that her tap water is of mediocre quality, because of the presence of pesticide metabolites. From this first entity, on which she has no hold at all, she works back to the question of where the water comes from, to the water authority that draws it from the river Orne, to the three management plans that share out the catchment area and whose periods of application have come to an end, then to the geology that explains this division, plain, hedged farmland, plain, and to the ways of inhabiting that follow from it. She explains why this story is her own:

“It starts from a concernement that is personal and that calls on us, because it’s the pebble in the shoe, it’s something that gnaws at us from the inside and that is what will push us to get involved. That’s why it’s a story in the first person.”

Élisabeth Taudière, talk at the conference “Transformations des politiques culturelles”, Cerisy, 20 June 2026.

The project Nous sommes Orne (We are Orne) was born from there, led by Territoires pionniers with the two environmental education centres (CPIE) of the catchment area, Le Dôme and Le Pavillon, in Caen. Its first achievement was a map of the catchment area, which did not exist in a form the public could read, and which is now found in classrooms, researchers’ offices and bars; the second is an almanac, the Almanach d’Olina. Habiter les paysages, composed by the landscape architect Clémence Mathieu from workshops held in primary schools, in a secondary school and in a betting bar in Briouze, which brings together residents’ practices and fictions written from the point of view of the springs, the meanders and the estuary. I take two things from this story for the method. First, the inquiry starts from a trouble felt by someone, and this trouble, put into words in the first person, is already a form of knowledge about the situation. Second, the people among whom the inquiry was carried out receive in return the objects produced, a map, an almanac, and they use them without those who made them being there.

In the Cerisy lexicon I kept the word “concernement” (the act of making people concerned), which comes from work on collective inquiry and urbanism in the wake of Latour. Whereas, in a public consultation, one starts from a project that is already tied up, ticks a regulatory box and collects opinions, concernement consists in going to find people in what already touches them, starting from their stories and their uses, and giving them a hold on the decision. Maud Le Floc’h puts it on the basis of her experience of urban development operations, where professionals say that their problem is people, whose legal challenges they fear above all:

“Collective inquiry, inquiring collectively, is a magnificent tool for urbanism, it’s a magnificent tool for concerning, another Latourian term, the greatest number. […] Collective because the stakes of transition, the stakes of transforming territories, if they are not carried by everyone, it won’t work. […] It’s a matter of taking charge of these subjects collectively. And to take charge of them properly, we might as well go back one phase earlier, and inquire together.”

Maud Le Floc’h, talk at the conference “Transformations des politiques culturelles”, Cerisy, 20 June 2026.

These practitioners also widen the inquiry to entities that are not human. The Parlement de Loire (Parliament of the Loire), which POLAU has been running since 2019, starts from Bruno Latour’s Parliament of Things, where non-human entities have the right to be represented in the bodies that decide their fate. The first gesture was a game: let’s pretend we’re holding a parliamentary commission of inquiry, and we’d hear lawyers, ecologists, fishermen, artists, on what the river is asking for. Maud Le Floc’h makes clear that the recognition of legal personality for the river is not what interests her most; she works on what she calls the landing of the inquiry in territorial planning, development plans, water quality, solidarity between upstream and downstream, swimming in the city, everyday subjects that translate into decisions. In the lexicon I proposed moving from the word “territory”, which designates what is carved up and appropriated, to the word “milieu”, which designates what we are part of. Cultural rights are the rights of persons, and they do not extend to the river. But the dignity of the people who live in a catchment area depends on the water they drink, and one cannot, if one wants to respect them, leave the water out of the frame. Inquiring in a milieu obliges us to ask who is missing around the table, including among what does not speak.

Scouting before diagnosing

Maud Le Floc’h describes the classic chain of an urban development operation: diagnosis, definition, programming, design, construction, delivery, the whole spread over five to ten years. Culture was most often invited only at the very end, at the inauguration, what Pascal Le Brun-Cordier calls the cherry on the cake. She proposes bringing it in at the very beginning, at the diagnosis phase, which she prefers to call scouting (repérage):

“What are artists going to spot when they place their own work in public space? They will go looking for the invisible, they will go looking for stories, they will go looking for what is buried, they will go looking for what is discarded, they will go looking for what is dirty, they will go looking for what is improper, they will go looking for values that are not necessarily always indicated in a classic diagnosis. Then they will speak to people.”

Maud Le Floc’h, talk at the conference “Transformations des politiques culturelles”, Cerisy, 20 June 2026.

One of the first schemes she designed was in fact called “Mission Repérage(s), un élu, un artiste” (Scouting mission, one elected official, one artist): in thirteen towns, between 2002 and 2005, a mayor or deputy mayor and an artist spent twelve hours together, in the morning the artist looked at the town, in the afternoon the elected official showed it to them, they walked as a pair, with no camera and no recording. These strict rules made possible encounters that would not have taken place without them. This is what I called, in the lexicon, a protocol, a precise framework that makes possible what could not be ordered directly.

Scouting is not enough, because a well-described problem often remains posed within the very frame in which it took shape. Here Maud Le Floc’h refers to the Palo Alto school and to what Paul Watzlawick, John Weakland and Richard Fisch named second-order change in Change: Principles of Problem Formation and Problem Resolution (1974). They describe there how most attempted solutions consist of “more of the same”, that is, an increased effort within the frame in which the problem took shape, and how, by staying within that frame, one maintains the problem one wanted to solve. Second-order change consists in stepping out of the frame, often through a paradoxical gesture or an inversion, what they call the gentle art of reframing. The Parlement de Loire belongs to this gesture, since by making the river speak in a fictional parliamentary chamber, those who inquire there no longer pose the question of developing the riverbanks from the point of view of the developer, but from the point of view of what is being developed. In the lexicon I called this the side-step, and noted that it is not always well received, because it touches on power and on the place one speaks from. For an inquiry, I conclude that fiction, role reversal, the hearing of what does not speak, serve to reformulate the initial question, just as much as the interview or documentary analysis. I described a tool of this kind, a more modest one, in the article The moving debate revisited.

Traces people can use without us

The people who take part in an inquiry designed in this way take something away from it, independently of its scholarly results. Formulating the questions, examining the traces, writing the conclusions with others gives words and tools that each person can then use again in their professional or civic life. I have experienced this in several ways. In the process I presented in the article Research-action « Image Education 2.1 », the professionals took part in working out the very thing that was being studied. In the article An advocacy document written by twelve people in one afternoon I described a co-writing workshop whose participants left with a text they had written together and which each of them could use on their own side. And for the Collaborative assessment of screen literacy education in Nouvelle-Aquitaine, carried out with ALCA in 2025-2026, some twenty professionals worked for four months on a contribution platform and wrote together a publication in eight chapters; the document matters less than the network born of this shared writing.

The opposite experience also exists, and many have lived it: consultative schemes where people talk a great deal, in groups, with sticky notes, and of which nothing remains but promised summaries, sometimes never received, which people can in any case never use themselves. Something is indeed produced there, discussion, shared reflection, and that product has its value. But people take away nothing they can reuse, and the words collected feed a document that will live its life without them. Marielle Stinès, cultural action adviser at the DRAC Normandie (the regional office of the Ministry of Culture), told at Cerisy the case of a group of rural municipalities in the Perche which, engaged in a regional cultural rights scheme beginning with a diagnosis, had wanted to lead the inquiry itself rather than entrust it to a consultancy. The local authority had sent a questionnaire to residents and received 285 answers, which is a lot for a mailing of this kind, then, once the answers had been processed, its elected officials and staff had not known what to do with them, and the regional budget planned for what came next had remained untouched. An eight-week residency, during which artists collected and gave back in a sensitive form what residents had said, had met a similar fate, since the elected officials, by her account, had retained the presence of the artists and the liveliness they created more than what the residents had said. In both cases, nobody had decided with the local authority, before collecting these words, what would be done with them. The film-maker Pascale Labout presented the project “Des chemins de culture” (Paths of culture), for which she and Marielle Stinès started again from the only thing everyone had retained from the answers to the questionnaire, the massive practice of hiking, to make it the guiding thread of an approach that was both participatory and artistic. Marielle Stinès borrowed from the cultural centres of Wallonia an expression I find apt, the “shared analysis of the territory”: the decree of 21 November 2013 that governs these centres requires every cultural action project to rest on such an analysis. She summed up its intention as follows:

“The idea was to warm up the cold data of diagnoses with more embodied data that would come from the residents themselves.”

Marielle Stinès, talk at the conference “Transformations des politiques culturelles”, Cerisy, 21 June 2026.

The criterion I propose comes down to one question to ask at the design stage: at the end of the process, what will the people who took part take away with them, that they will be able to use without us? To it I add two words from the Cerisy lexicon. Collectage, the collecting practised by ethnomusicologists such as Jean-Claude Lemenuel, supposes time, trust, acceptance by those to whose homes one comes, and the principle that one does not cross a territory where one is not welcomed. Restitution, for me, is about the process more than about the result: giving back the path travelled, with the traces kept of it, allows people to recognise themselves in what they have worked out and to assess their own progress, whereas, if only the result is given back, one feels obliged to embellish it so that it reflects well on everyone.

Eight gestures for inquiring with people

I propose to translate all this into gestures that can be carried out in a diagnosis commissioned by a local authority as well as in a master’s dissertation, with the means one has:

  • Write down your own concernement before writing the question. A page in the first person, before any choice of field or method, where I say what troubles me in this situation, what I depend on and who depends on me. A student writes it before choosing her subject; in an agency, it is written before answering a commission, and the client is asked to do the same. This page is the starting compass, and one returns to it at the end to measure what has moved.
  • Put the commissioned question up for discussion before dealing with it. The first session with the people concerned is not for asking them questions but for submitting to them the one we were asked: is it the right one, and if not, what is the real one? We accept that it may change. The reformulation of the object, documented, is already a result of the inquiry, often the most useful one.
  • Draw up an inventory of the entities, human and non-human. On the model of the compass, place with the group everything that plays a part in the situation, people and institutions, but also the river, the building, the budget line, the regulations, noting what one has a hold on and what one does not. One then sees who is missing, and goes to find those who are absent before going any further.
  • Scout before diagnosing, on foot. Before any questionnaire, a time of scouting according to a protocol: two people, a fixed duration, one looks and the other shows, no recording, then each writes down what they saw. An artist, when one can be brought in, looks for what does not fit into any box. For a dissertation, there is much to gain from replacing the interview in a room with the interview conducted while walking, in the places being talked about.
  • Make yourself take a side-step. At least once in the process, a fiction or an inversion through which the frame is shifted: hearing what does not speak, asking each person to speak by putting themselves in someone else’s place, holding a moving debate on the initial question. What is expected from it is not an answer, but a reframing, in Watzlawick’s sense, which makes visible what was taken for granted in the initial frame.
  • Collect with the people, and leave them the traces. At each meeting, the participants make a trace, a photograph, a recorded sentence, an annotated map, and this trace stays with them, on a medium they can consult and add to, a shared platform or a simple shared folder. The sticky note that leaves in the facilitator’s bag is the counter-model. Permission to keep these traces is asked for, as in collectage, and people are told what will be done with them.
  • Write with, not after. The conclusions are written in session, with the people, in co-writing workshops of which I described one form in the article “An advocacy document written by twelve people in one afternoon”. The final text bears the names of those who wrote it. For a dissertation or a thesis, at least one chapter can be worked out in this way, and the way it was done is part of the method set out.
  • Put the restitution in the schedule and in the budget before starting. The date of the return to the people is set at the time of the commission, not at the end, because restitution is the first thing to be sacrificed when time runs short. The process is then given back, with its traces, in a shared language, to the people first and to the client afterwards. And for those who would like to take up the approach elsewhere, one writes down what can be taken from it on condition that it is translated into another context, and not copied.

Being accountable to the people as much as to the client

An inquiry led with people demands more rigour than an inquiry carried out on them: situations have to be documented, traces kept, the way conclusions emerge from them made explicit, and it has to be said who wrote what. This rigour also concerns those to whom one is accountable. Jean-Louis Bancel, president of the Association des Amis de Pontigny-Cerisy, proposed with regard to public money the word “redevabilité” (accountability), that is, giving an account of one’s mandate to those in whose name one acts, which is not the same thing as producing an impact study. When an inquiry has been led with people, one is accountable to them at the same time as to the client, and that is another way of answering for public money.

Being accountable does not mean effacing oneself, and I experienced this on my film « Droit à la parole ! », a documentary on the democratic organisation of a progressive school. I conducted the editing through back-and-forth with those who commissioned the film, for six months, showing them each stage. What I did not dare to do at the outset, bringing my own point of view into the film, became possible because each version was discussed, and I took my place far better than I would have done alone. The expert cuts their words to the measure of what their client can hear; the person who is accountable along the way discovers what their client can hear, and it is often more than one thought. Then we showed the film to all the people who appear in it, children and adults, before any screening. We had the image rights releases; so it was not a matter of law but of ethics, the same as for the restitution of an inquiry: people must be able to agree with what is said about them before it circulates without them.

In the article Transmitting cultural rights : a question of coherence I argued that the way of transmitting is part of the message. The same requirement holds for the way of studying. When those who inquire respect people’s dignity, have them take part and recognise what they know, in their very way of working, they give by example the proof of what they will later assert in their conclusions.

In the section Cultural rights 42 publications

How to cite Benoît Labourdette, “Inquiring in the spirit of cultural rights”, Benoît Labourdette production, 12 September 2026.
https://www.benoitlabourdette.com/les-ressources/les-droits-culturels/enqueter-selon-les-droits-culturels?lang=en

This is a long read: you can take it with you.

Download as PDF