People often believe that learning among peers is confining: people working together, without someone who knows better than they do, would learn less than with an expert. Young people think so, and many adults too, who go looking elsewhere, in a big city, a renowned school or a training course, for what they believe they cannot find among themselves. I argue the opposite, provided the group does not simply reassure itself among its own. When it invents its own way of doing things, it builds a frame that is its own, and its members then feed this frame with outside contributions, those of adults, teachers, social media or the culture we inherit, instead of replacing it with them. I draw on Jacques Rancière, on the psychologist Lev Vygotsky and on two educational experiences of my own, a conversation with a high school student and the years when I accompanied my younger son outside any school system, to propose a way of supporting people who are learning.
Going where the people who know are
A few days ago, I spoke on the phone with a final-year high school student who lives in a small provincial town and wants to work in cinema. She already makes films with her friends, as part of her school’s film option, but she asked me how to find what she called “a real shooting experience”, and whether she should go to Paris to have it, with professionals. She summed up what she did with her friends like this: “I know we can do things among ourselves and all that.” In her sentence, I heard this “among ourselves” as a stopgap, a way of passing the time while waiting to learn for real, elsewhere and with others.
This idea is not specific to young people. When I run training courses for professionals who work with young people, I am often asked for tools, methods, someone who knows. In « So what do we offer them ? », I explained that behind this request I mostly hear each person’s isolation, since other people, in the same room or in the organisation next door, have often already found how to deal with situations that worry others. This knowledge is there, scattered, and nobody considers it real knowledge; my work mainly consists in getting it to circulate among the people present. In both cases, people assume that knowledge lies elsewhere, with those who know more, and that one has to go to them to receive it.
I am not saying one should never leave, nor that it is useless to meet more experienced people. Staying among one’s own exists, and it can be very comfortable: you meet people there who stay among themselves, who reassure each other, never question themselves and do not seek at all to open up to others. They do not learn much. The peer group I am talking about here invents something, and it goes outside to look for what its project needs. I would like to question what we expect from leaving, and what we lose when we disparage what we do with people who are at the same stage as ourselves.
Forming or formatting
What is training? In French, the word formation comes from the Latin formare, to give a form. The question is who gives the form, and to what. In the usual vision of teaching, it is the teacher who gives it and the pupil who receives it: we know in advance what the person must know at the end, and we lead them there. Computing has a word for this operation: formatting. To format a disk is to impose a prior structure on it, so that it can then receive data arranged according to that structure, and that structure alone. I believe that in many of our training courses, we do the same thing. We force people to think according to a logic that is not theirs, and to set aside their singular way of thinking, since it does not fit into the boxes provided.
Jacques Rancière gave this question a story that I often quote. In Le Maître ignorant (The Ignorant Schoolmaster, Fayard, 1987), he tells how, in 1818, Joseph Jacotot, a lecturer in French literature at the University of Louvain, found himself in front of Flemish students whose language he did not speak. Through an interpreter, he had them given a bilingual edition of Télémaque, published in Brussels, and asked them to learn the French text with the help of the translation. He explained neither spelling nor conjugation to them. When he asked them to write in French what they thought of the book, he expected gross mistakes. He discovered instead that these students, left to themselves, had managed as well as many French people would have, and that they wrote, says Rancière, “the sentences of writers and not of schoolchildren”. Jacotot had done nothing more than put them in front of the book, with the instruction to manage on their own:
“He had left them alone with Fénelon’s text, a translation – not even an interlinear one, as in schools – and their will to learn French. He had only given them the order to cross a forest whose exits he did not know.”
Jacques Rancière, “Le Maître ignorant”, 1987 (my translation).
These students were responsible for their own learning, and nobody more learned than they were stood between them and the text. Rancière draws on this adventure to criticise the pedagogy of explanation, and his critique still seems to me just as accurate. The teacher who explains, even with the best intentions, starts by setting up a distance between their knowledge and the pupil’s ignorance, then takes it upon themselves to reduce it, and the pupil ends up believing they cannot understand anything without them:
“The revelation that came to Joseph Jacotot amounts to this: the logic of the explanatory system must be reversed. Explanation is not necessary to remedy an incapacity to understand. On the contrary, this incapacity is the structuring fiction of the explanatory conception of the world. It is the explainer who needs the incapable and not the other way round; it is he who constitutes the incapable as such. To explain something to someone is first of all to show him that he cannot understand it by himself.”
Jacques Rancière, “Le Maître ignorant”, 1987 (my translation).
Rancière reports another memory of Jacotot, who had seen young men selected in haste arrive at the École polytechnique during the Revolution, and had seen them become very good mathematicians, writes Rancière, “less through the mathematics that Monge or Lagrange explained to them than through the mathematics they did in front of them”. These young men learned by doing, in front of their teachers and among themselves.
I took up this idea in « So what do we offer them ? », about the training courses I run for professionals, and in The Fertile Margin, where I wrote that we know differently from the people we work with, and not better than them. At a participatory talk in Grenoble this autumn, I summed it up in one sentence, which I reported in A person in front of an audience and a screen behind: “when you consider that you know better than someone, you reduce their capacity”.
People at the same stage
One might object that people who learn together lack knowledge. That is true; there are always people somewhere who would know better than they do how to go about things. Margaret Mead called cofigurative the culture in which one learns mainly from one’s peers, and in I do not know the world you will live in I recalled that adults tend to disparage it. What a peer group loses in already established knowledge, I believe it gains in invention: lacking a model, it has to invent its way of doing things, and in doing so, it also invents its own language.
Paulo Freire said it in one sentence, in Pedagogy of the Oppressed (1968): “nobody educates anybody else, nobody educates himself, people educate one another through the mediation of the world” (my translation from the French edition). Lev Vygotsky, for his part, described what is called the zone of proximal development, the gap between what a person can do alone and what they become able to do with the support of others; I discussed it in The Thirty Seconds That Belong to Them. This support does not necessarily come from an adult or an expert. It can come from a fellow learner who understood something a little before you, and who still remembers it well enough to share it in their own words. Ivan Illich, in Deschooling Society (1971), already proposed replacing part of the school institution with networks in which people would find other people interested in the same questions as themselves, in order to learn together.
Peers still have to be given the chance to learn this way. At the end of October 2026, in Tours, people housed by the association Entraide et Solidarités shot, in three days, with the artist Rosalie Lescure and myself, short films explaining their rights to the people who will arrive after them, as I recounted in Twenty-seven films so that rights don’t end up in a drawer. On the third day, in another accommodation centre, the director, very proud of the films from the first two days, suggested showing them to the new group, to make them want to take part. I said no. These films had been made by people living the same situation, but the third day’s group would have told themselves: they are good, and we are bad. People who share the same social situation nonetheless have different skills, and they establish hierarchies among themselves. I explained this refusal in detail, along with the psychology research that sheds light on it, in Show the tool, not the result.
This is not withdrawal, however. Inventing together what we do does not mean living in isolation. We are part of a culture, we receive things, adults can bring us things, we also learn a great deal on social media, and teachers can teach us things. The difference lies in the frame within which these contributions arrive. When I invent it myself with others, I bring the contributions into my logic, my ideas, the connections I have already made, and I use them for a project that is ours. We can then make use of the skills of each person, and even of very old knowledge, but within this new frame we are building. In a photography workshop that I described in Cultural Mediation as a Device for Symbolic Emancipation, those who had trouble putting their images online got help from the others, and I did not step in: skills were distributed across the group, and everyone could contribute something.
Putting things into words
This frame is shaped in dialogue. Speaking is not bringing out what was already inside oneself. It is giving form to one’s thought, working out things one perhaps did not think before formulating them, in other words building oneself. Psychoanalysis calls this the process of symbolisation, and I described what it produces in a group in Symbolization as a tool for mobilization. We have all experienced it: we get stuck on a problem, we decide to talk to someone about it, and it is by formulating the question that we find the answer.
Lev Vygotsky showed this from the side of developmental psychology. In Thinking and Speech (1934), he writes that “thought is not expressed but completed in the word” (in Norris Minick’s translation). The linguist Émile Benveniste made a similar observation in 1958, in “Subjectivity in Language”: “it is in and through language that man constitutes himself as a subject” (my translation). I presented these two lines of thought in The transformative power of speech, and in Building, Not Valorizing the idea, also formulated by Vygotsky, that what first happens between people later becomes a capacity of each person. If thought takes shape as it is spoken, then whoever is learning first needs a space to work things out aloud, in front of someone who is really listening. If they are handed ready-made knowledge before their own question has taken shape, they have little chance of holding on to it.
A peer group often offers this space better than a teacher does, because everyone in it speaks to people who do not know the answer in advance. When a more learned person is present, they can offer it too, provided they delay the moment when they give their opinion, and begin by listening.
Listening before answering
Let me come back to the high school student who called me. When I reread our conversation, I see that I did not answer her straight away. I first asked her what year she was in and which subjects she was taking, then what she wanted to do, telling her that this was what mattered most. She told me about screenwriting and the image. I asked her whether she had a personal practice, outside what she did at school. She replied that “unfortunately” she had not yet done much on her own, and I asked her why she said “unfortunately”, then what was holding her back. Next, I rephrased what I had understood of what attracted her, creation rather than running cinemas, for example, and I asked whether she wanted to tell me anything else that would help me know her better. When she asked her main question, I asked her once more, before answering, whether she had other things to tell me.
I often proceed this way: I ask questions to understand for as long as I do not yet know who I am talking to. When I finally answered her question about the “real shooting experience”, I was able to start from what she had told me about herself. She already knew people in her town, she was already shooting with her friends, and I told her she could already do a great deal there. I told her that meeting new people opens your mind, of course, but that going deeper with the people you already know is also very valuable, and that it is better not to be dazzled by things that shine. The most important encounters are not always the ones you imagined. I also told her that this was my personal point of view. And at the end I suggested she write to me from time to time to let me know how she was getting on.
There is nothing spectacular about this way of doing things, and anyone can take it up. It rests on a simple idea, which Carl Rogers developed in On Becoming a Person (1961), and which I presented in The One Who Makes Nothing: a person finds within themselves the means to move forward, provided they are given the chance to say what they are looking for. Listening for a long time before answering lets the other person’s frame take shape, so that one can then contribute something to it.
An hour a day
I lived this way of doing things more continuously with my younger son. He left school from the first year of middle school, for complex family reasons, and from the age of sixteen he lived with me for five years, outside any school system. He learned with me. We had not designed a method at the outset; things simply happened that way. He was asking himself important questions, he trusted me, and he knew I would try to help him, without seeking to impose my thinking on him. About once a day, then, he would come and ask me a big question, on a subject that mattered to him, which could be extremely broad: a question about learning, reflection, life, philosophy, etc. I knew we would need an hour and a half, and that I had to be there for him. If I was not available, if I did not feel able to be open at that moment, I told him so, and we made an appointment for a precise time later in the day.
What does it mean to be able to listen? For me, it means having time open to the other person: not thinking about something else at the same time, not being preoccupied with one’s own affairs. It is easy to say, and it is very difficult work, which requires creating a mental space within oneself for the other person, all the more so when that person is part of one’s daily life, and is one’s own child. I do not claim to have always managed it. My elder son once told me, very explicitly: “but you’re not listening to me”. I learned as I went along.
By listening to him in this way, I was already giving my son legitimacy. I made myself available for his questions, and in doing so I signalled to him that they were important; the situation itself had something constructive about it. I first listened to him set out his problem, and I asked him questions to understand it. Sometimes these were very technical computing questions, whose subtleties I did not fully grasp; I would then ask him to explain the logic to me. I asked these questions first for myself, but in answering them he worked things out, and he sometimes found his answer simply by explaining his problem to me. When the answer did not come, I asked him more precise questions, to help him dig into the subject in his own way.
Linking contributions to the other person’s question
It was at that point that I could offer him something: tools, my point of view, making clear that it was only mine, ways of looking or analysing, cultural references. But I soon noticed that if what I was saying was not linked to a question he had identified as his own, he immediately got bored and stopped taking anything in. That was where the tension in these moments lay: understanding his frame and recognising it as legitimate, instead of making him believe that my adult frame was more important than his.
I react the same way. If someone tells me things that do not interest me, I lose my attention, and we have probably all asked someone for advice and been answered with a host of things we could not take in. I sometimes spoke for quite a long time; it depended on the day. But I was not trying to win him over, nor to make sure he was listening to me; I was trying to make what I said connect with his concerns. That did not rule out detours. I could talk to him about things very far from his subject, when I saw a link and a possible light on his question. There was nothing narrow-minded about it, nor any narrow efficiency. One can open things up very widely, provided one understands, and says, why one is connecting one thing to another.
Each of these moments was, I believe, an important stage in his development, and I felt I was playing my role as an adult. That role consisted in offering his thinking a space in which to take shape, and in placing contributions there at the moment when he could bring them into his own logic. Today, without having studied, he has built himself a professional life that suits him and is very solid. He has a grip on reality that few people have. His character no doubt has a lot to do with it, but I believe his education also has something to do with it, an education made of the questions he asked himself and that we took the time to work on together. I believe this is also what happens in a group of people learning together, young or adult, when those who know more agree not to hand them a ready-made frame: each person learns in dialogue, and that is where each person can make room for the contributions of others, peers and elders alike. Rancière says nothing different when he distinguishes the teacher who explains from the teacher who emancipates: the latter does not pass on his knowledge, he obliges the other to use their own intelligence, and he believes them capable of doing so.
Supporting someone who is learning
To conclude, here are a few ways of doing things, whether you are supporting a group or a single person, young people or adults, in a training course, a workshop, at home or on the phone:
- Let the person set out their frame before proposing your own. I start by asking what they are looking for, what they have already done and what bothers them, and I pick up on the words that matter to them, like the student’s “unfortunately”.
- Ask questions to understand, first for yourself. When I do not understand everything, especially on a technical subject, I ask the person to explain the logic of their problem to me; in explaining it, they often move forward on their own.
- Rephrase, then ask if there is anything else. I say what I have understood, and I ask, sometimes two or three times, whether the person wants to add something before I answer.
- Link every contribution to a question the person has formulated. I can share tools, references or very distant detours, provided I say why I am connecting them to their question.
- Say that it is a point of view. I make clear that what I suggest comes from my own path, and that others will tell them something else.
- Value what is done “among ourselves”. A film shot with friends, a practice exchanged between colleagues, are already learning experiences, and I tell this to the people who disparage them.
- Don’t show other people’s successes at the outset. Before people have done anything, I show how the tool works, not finished films, as I explained in Show the tool, not the result.
- Let skills circulate within the group. When someone gets stuck, I first invite them to ask their neighbours for help, and I only step in afterwards.
- Make yourself available, or postpone. If I am not in a state to listen, I say so, and I suggest a precise time when I will be, rather than listening with half an ear.